This set of bells all ring nicely. There are 5 in all. They need to be cleaned. They do not react to a magnet so they may be brass. The leather strap they were on broke in my hands so the leather is very dried out. I am not familiar with bells so I don't have any knowledge of what you may need to consider this purchase so feel free to contact me with questions. They have been in a smoke free environment. We must collect 6% Pennsylvania Sales Use Tax at checkout. Thanks for stopping by!